In-House vs Agency vs Fractional: The Full-Cost Comparison
Related service: Budget reallocation
For most companies under about $50M in revenue, a fractional lead plus an agency or plan costs less than one full-time marketing manager and covers more skills. A hire wins when marketing needs someone leading a team every day. Compare the options on three-year full cost, not salary versus retainer.
In this article
Why salary vs retainer is the wrong comparison
A salary is the smallest part of what a hire costs. A retainer is usually most of what an agency costs. Put them side by side and the hire looks cheap, which is why so many companies hire first and regret it later.
Compare full cost over three years instead. That's long enough to include hiring, ramp-up and at least one change in the team.
What a hire really costs
- Pay. Use your state's market rate, not what you hope to pay.
- Benefits and payroll taxes. Health insurance, retirement and employer taxes add a large share on top of pay. We use 30% as a starting assumption. Use your own number if you know it.
- Software and training. The tools a marketer needs to do the job, per seat.
- Hiring. Recruiter fees or your own team's time. We use 15% of first-year pay.
- Ramp time. Months of salary before the person is fully productive.
- Management time. Someone has to set goals and review the work. Usually that's you.
- Coverage. One person brings one skill set. Strategy, writing, design, ads, SEO and analytics rarely live in one head.
Worked example: one marketing manager in Missouri
| Line | Year one | Years two and three, each |
|---|---|---|
| Median pay (BLS, Missouri) | $110,400 | $110,400 |
| Benefits and payroll taxes, 30% | $33,100 | $33,100 |
| Software and training | $2,400 | $2,400 |
| Hiring, 15% of pay | $16,600 | n/a |
| Total | $162,500 | $145,900 |
Three years: about $454,300, for one person's skills. Pay is the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics median for marketing managers in Missouri (May 2023). The other lines are assumptions you can change in the Marketing Team Cost Calculator.
What the alternatives cost
Three years of a Mazey plan runs from $90,000 at $2,500 a month to $360,000 at $10,000 a month. Each plan covers strategy and execution across several skills. A fractional lead on their own can cost less, but usually needs an agency or freelancers alongside to get the work done.
The question isn't which number is lowest. It's which number buys the outcome you need, with the least management from you.
What each option is good at
| Option | Best when | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|
| Full-time hire | Marketing is big enough to lead a team daily | Ramp time, turnover, one person's blind spots |
| Fractional lead | You need senior judgment, not a full salary | Strategy without anyone to execute it |
| Agency or plan | You need work done well and fast | Losing ownership of accounts and data |
| Mix of the above | You're growing past one person | Nobody owning the whole picture |
What you should own either way
Whichever you choose, keep these in your company's name: your domain, website, analytics, ad accounts, CRM, social profiles and the written strategy. A partner should have access, not ownership. The Asset Ownership Checklist lists all sixteen.
How to decide in three questions
- How much daily oversight does the work need? Daily points to a hire. Weekly points to fractional or a plan.
- How many skills do you need covered? More than two points away from a single hire.
- What does three-year full cost look like for each? Run it for your state before you post a job.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, Missouri, May 2023 (Marketing Managers, 11-2021).